PROVENANCE. Collectors, Dealers and Scholars in the Field of Chinese Ceramics in Britain and America
By: Roy Davids & Dominic Jellinek
Review by Jan-Erik Nilsson on June 26th, 2013 // Filed under Hand and Reference Books
Davids, Roy & Jellinek, Dominic: PROVENANCE. Collectors, Dealers and Scholars in the Field of Chinese Ceramics in Britain and America. Great Haseley, 2011. 500 pp. Over 150 illustrations. 28×22 cm. Cloth.
A major resource for the provenance of Chinese ceramics from collections in Britain and America. Contains 1064 biographies of collectors, dealers and scholars from the 17th century collector, Queen Mary II, onwards to the 20th century. A 40 page introduction traces ceramic contacts between China and Britain and America from the 16th to the 21st centuries. Also includes sections on fakes, the psychology of collecting, a dissertation on export versus domestic wares and much more. Numerous appendices including one on collectors’ labels.
Certainly not the best book to study the ceramics themselves, but if you are interested in the impact of Chinese ceramics collecting in the western culture, this book is irreplaceable.
This book deals primarily with the collecting of Chinese ceramics – and probably 90%+ of the book consists of short biographies of collectors in the UK and US. The mind behind the book is Dominic Jellinek, a former Director of Bluett & Sons in London, who acquired the Bluett archives when the business closed some years ago.
All biographies are of deceased collectors/dealers for the most part, and the book is stronger on the more well known ones. For less prominent (more private) collectors, the biographies might be thin, and they will likely have made it to the book as their collections were sold by either one of the large auction houses or dealers in London and New York.
The introduction presents the only ‘readable material’ – while the remainder is more for reference. However, this section is quite interesting as it deals with the ceramics contact between Europe/America and China over the centuries. As such, one gets a good idea of the type of pieces that made the journey to Europe/America over time.
There is also a short section on fakes, which is perhaps not ground-breaking, but still worth the read. Lastly, there is a small selection of collector/dealer labels. However, to avoid feeding more information to the fakers, these are all quite small, grainy, and in black and white. However, they give a broad indication as to what a label from say Bluett would have looked like, including several versions over the time period of the company.
So is this book worth it? It’s a steep price, but it will surely only get more expensive. It is an excellent reference book for those who prefer to collect pieces with provenance, especially those that occasionally appear at dealers in London, of which I recall having seen several of the names listed in the book over the years. When accompanied by catalogues from the dealers and auction houses that have sold off many of these collections, the book becomes more valuable, as the plates in the book do not add too much value.
For some of the lesser known collectors, the book would be of greater value, as information would not necessarily be readily available. What the book will not do is to help a buyer assess the actual piece, and the plates included in the book are more illustrations of particular pieces from collections and interior shots from dealer rooms. They add flavor – not substance. As to the information on the various collectors, dealers etc. I don’t think there are any disputes as to the book’s quality – in fact the British Museum donor bios will frequently reference this work. This book should perhaps sit next to Stacey Pierson’s “Collectors, Collections and Museums – The Field of Chinese Ceramics in Britain, 1560-1960” in your book shelf – as they would likely complement each other.
– Do not get this book to study ceramics
– Do not get this book as a visual reference to identify pieces
– Do not get this book if the topic of provenance is not relevant to your collection
– Do get this book if you want concise bios of English and American collectors for reference purposes
(The review is culled from the book recommendation section on the Gotheborg Discussion Board)
Leave a Comment
You must be logged in to post a comment.